CrowdFreeViews
Two pigs walking on a white-sand beach beside turquoise water in the BahamasA windswept divi-divi tree on the white sand of Eagle Beach, Aruba

Bahamas vs Aruba in September

Aruba edges it in September. Bahamas averages 24–31°C with low crowds; Aruba 27–33°C with low crowds.

By Daan · Last reviewed October 2026

Bahamas and Aruba

The verdict for September

  • WeatherAruba has the better weather4.5/10 vs 8.5/10
  • CrowdsVery similarLow vs Low
  • PricesVery similar$ vs $$
  • OverallAruba comes out ahead4.5/10 vs 8/10
Two pigs walking on a white-sand beach beside turquoise water in the Bahamas

Bahamas in September

Peak hurricane risk, very quiet

Temperature
24–31°C
Crowds
Low
Prices
$

+Lowest prices and empty beaches.

–Highest storm risk and heavy rain.

September is the cheapest and quietest month, if you accept the storm risk.

A windswept divi-divi tree on the white sand of Eagle Beach, Aruba

Aruba in September

Quiet month

Temperature
27–33°C
Crowds
Low
Prices
$$

+Low prices, calm sea.

–The hottest weather.

September is the quietest month, with calm water and the best deals.

Scores and crowd levels are my own judgement; temperatures are monthly averages. Higher scores are better: quieter, cheaper and more pleasant.