CrowdFreeViews
Two pigs walking on a white-sand beach beside turquoise water in the BahamasA windswept divi-divi tree on the white sand of Eagle Beach, Aruba

Bahamas vs Aruba in May

Aruba edges it in May. Bahamas averages 21–29°C with low crowds; Aruba 27–32°C with moderate crowds.

By Daan · Last reviewed October 2026

Bahamas and Aruba

The verdict for May

  • WeatherAruba has the better weather7.5/10 vs 9/10
  • CrowdsVery similarLow vs Moderate
  • PricesVery similar$$ vs $$$
  • OverallAruba comes out ahead8.5/10 vs 9/10
Two pigs walking on a white-sand beach beside turquoise water in the Bahamas

Bahamas in May

Best overall: warm, quiet, cheaper

Temperature
21–29°C
Crowds
Low
Prices
$$

+Warm sea, quiet beaches, lower prices.

–Rainier, and hurricane season is near.

May is warm and beach-ready, with fewer visitors and lower prices. The hurricane season doesn't start until June 1.

A windswept divi-divi tree on the white sand of Eagle Beach, Aruba

Aruba in May

Best value

Temperature
27–32°C
Crowds
Moderate
Prices
$$$

+Dry, sunny, lower prices.

–Few events.

May is dry and quiet, one of the best-value months.

Scores and crowd levels are my own judgement; temperatures are monthly averages. Higher scores are better: quieter, cheaper and more pleasant.